Everyone who is panning this should watch Olaf Presents or Once Upon a Snowman to see how dismal Olaf shorts can be.
I actually didn’t hate this one! It’s a good-faith effort to add a little bit of depth to the world and characters of Frozen. The trauma of the loneliness and “lost years” of Anna’s and Elsa’s childhood are given some consideration. There are a couple of cool animation choices, including a segment that looks to recreate the texture of hand-knit yarn sweaters.
I also thought the way it connected Olaf to the memory of “Do You Want to Build a Snowman,” i.e. Anna’s and Elsa’s limited connection during their youth, was actually kind of touching.
And a couple moments made me chuckle, like Sven impersonating Olaf, and the chaos of the sleigh losing control and falling off a cliff.
Okay, sure, Olaf is an immensely annoying character, the songs are rushed throwaways, and the story is inessential. It is still, quite squarely, not a good piece of entertainment. But considering how low my expectations were, I had a half-decent time.
Is It Good?
Not Very Good (3/8)
Note: This review was published early in The Goods' history and is a candidate for an expanded review in the future. Please excuse brevity or inconsistencies in style.
Dan is the founder and head critic of The Goods. Follow Dan on Letterboxd. Join the Discord for updates and discussion.