Recent Comments

  • Hunter Allen on The Phoenician Scheme (2025):

    Y’know, I’m kinda eager to give this a rewatch, as maybe I missed the keener emotional hooks that do seem…

    Jun 27, 22:04


  • Dan Stalcup on Final Destination 3 (2006):

    The one and only Ramona Flowers, married to Obi-Wan Kenobi

    Jun 25, 21:38


  • ED on Final Destination 3 (2006):

    “She (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) tops Devon Sawa” That lucky, lucky man: may we all be so blessed and may we…

    Jun 23, 14:33


  • Dan Stalcup on Thin Ice (1937):

    Thanks for the recs and overview. I had trouble finding much written on them, so I appreciate it! Might hit…

    Jun 22, 18:21


  • Hunter Allen on Thin Ice (1937):

    Stickler’s note: “Republic” should be “International.” (Which of course merged with Universal.)

    Jun 20, 12:33


  • Hunter Allen on Thin Ice (1937):

    YEAH. You asked or I inferred the question elsewhere, so the highlights as I recall them go: Happy Landing (1938):…

    Jun 20, 12:31


  • Dan Stalcup on Beach Party (1963):

    Price’s cameo is very small, but of course he leaves an impression, and it plays well in re-watch knowing the…

    Jun 20, 08:22


  • Dan Stalcup on Friendship (2024):

    It’s definitely on the line between a 5 and a 6 for me! I wanted to give it room to…

    Jun 20, 07:37


  • Andrew Milne on Friendship (2024):

    Wow, this for sure reads more enthusiastically than I’d associate with a 5/8!

    Jun 20, 04:14


  • ED on Beach Party (1963):

    I admit that the only ‘California Sound’ I’m very familiar with is HOTEL CALIFORNIA (Eagles man, now and forever -…

    Jun 19, 14:08


  • Dan Stalcup on Beach Party (1963):

    Eleven sequels and spinoffs within 4 years. Asher himself directed and co-wrote 5 sequels that released in 1964 and 1965.…

    Jun 18, 11:09


  • Hunter Allen on Beach Party (1963):

    Checked it out, as I’d been meaning to for ages (I’ve owned the cheap DVD set–double sided? are you for…

    Jun 18, 02:50


  • Dan Stalcup on Beach Party (1963):

    Didn’t make it into the review, but… unlike all of its sequels (except Ski Party) Beach Party has only had…

    Jun 17, 07:03


  • Dan Stalcup on The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920):

    I’ve heard this take before, that it’s some sort of double twist meant to disguise Dr. Caligari’s real intents. I…

    Jun 14, 14:01


  • Son on The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920):

    I would not say that the ending undermines the movie by any means. The way it is filmed, there is…

    Jun 12, 12:32


  • Dan Stalcup on Greed (1924):

    Maybe it’s just the dying relevance of silent film in general but I hear people talk about Ambersons more than…

    Jun 11, 08:24


  • Dan Stalcup on Greed (1924):

    “I thought they smelled bad on the outside!” I actually agree with you that I don’t think a monolith 8-hour…

    Jun 11, 08:21


  • Andrew Milne on Greed (1924):

    Maybe only The Magnificent Ambersons equals Greed for the legend of what was lost to history.

    Jun 11, 06:51


  • Andrew Milne on Gangs of London, Season 3, Episode 8:

    That’s really sweet of you to say, Jo, thanks! Great to know that this series helped to enrich the show…

    Jun 11, 06:49


  • Hunter Allen on Greed (1924):

    Why, he’s got a giant bag just full of water right there. Does sound pretty cool, maybe I oughtta just…

    Jun 11, 02:20


  • Jo on Gangs of London, Season 3, Episode 8:

    Some seriously laugh aloud moments in this review. I especially liked ‘so I guess this congress of ultra-rich criminals operates…

    Jun 10, 15:16


  • ED on Final Destination 2 (2003):

    I’d say FEAR STREET as a whole lives in the good-not-great niche, but certainly has it’s pleasures.

    Jun 9, 06:21


  • Dan Stalcup on Final Destination 2 (2003):

    I have the Fear Streets queued up and will check them out at some point. I’ve heard nothing but anti-enthusiasm…

    Jun 6, 14:59


  • Dan Stalcup on The Great White Silence (1924):

    Aha. There you go. I see what you mean about the commercial viability of film restoration dilemma. As with many…

    Jun 6, 14:58


  • Hunter Allen on The Great White Silence (1924):

    Just to answer that question, new restorations are 100% not copyrightable. It’s probably the good and right thing, but it…

    Jun 4, 20:08


  • Andrew Milne on Gangs of London, Season 3, Episode 7:

    Thanks, man! Glad to know these write-ups have a real readership, it’s been gratifying to get these comments from yourself…

    Jun 4, 12:25


  • Hunter Allen on Final Destination 2 (2003):

    This one is my favorite, but 1 is an absolutely respectable choice, and maybe it really does have a bit…

    Jun 2, 21:32


  • ED on Final Destination 2 (2003):

    Oh, also, I recently watched FEAR STREET: PROM QUEEN on Netflix and thought that you might like a caution -…

    Jun 2, 11:48


  • ED on Final Destination 2 (2003):

    I recall seeing the second and third entries in this series – no wait, I also recall seeing the first…

    Jun 2, 11:46


  • Steve B on Gangs of London, Season 3, Episode 7:

    I’m so glad you picked up on the same jarring sense I got from that Merwan/Lale scene. It’s so weird.…

    Jun 1, 13:40


  • Andrew Milne on Gangs of London, Season 3, Episode 6:

    Lol, yeah, completely agreed on Shannon! I don’t think the writers ever quite figured out what to do with her,…

    May 30, 06:15


  • Hunter Allen on Wish (2023):

    1. Wish 2. Encanto 3. Raya and the Last Dragon 4. Frozen II 5. Strange World 6. Moana 2 7.…

    May 29, 20:44


  • Steve B on Gangs of London, Season 3, Episode 6:

    Sorry but i just dont buy or understand why Shannon has randomly done a 180 and now thinks nothing of…

    May 29, 17:50


  • Steve B on Gangs of London, Season 3, Episode 5:

    It was very silly with the writers now making Lale a stunning and brave invulnerable super girlboss….BUT, she’s still my…

    May 29, 16:46


  • Andrew Milne on Gangs of London, Season 1, Episode 6:

    Cheers, Sean!

    May 29, 16:07


  • Dan Stalcup on Wish (2023):

    May 29, 16:03


  • Dan Stalcup on Wish (2023):

    so no wish? (smashes star)

    May 29, 15:06


  • Dan Stalcup on Wish (2023):

    My rank is probably: 1. Frozen II 2. Encanto 3. Raya and the Last Dragon 4. Strange World 5. Wish…

    May 29, 14:00


  • Brian T on Wish (2023):

    The only part I liked were the little constellations of Milo Thatch and Wreck-It Ralph in the credits.

    May 29, 13:24


  • Brian T on Wish (2023):

    Pokémon Go to the polls.

    May 29, 13:21


  • Hunter Allen on Wish (2023):

    I still like it better than every other post-Moana WDAS film, but God almighty, that premise is like a bottomless…

    May 29, 12:17


  • Sean on Gangs of London, Season 1, Episode 6:

    Really well written and thoughtful review(s). Thanks for this.

    May 29, 01:29


  • ED on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    Like any sensible cinema fan I have repressed all memories of THE CONQUEROR starring Mr John Wayne. Also, the Omar…

    May 27, 13:12


  • Hunter Allen on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    I obviously meant “i.e.”

    May 26, 11:12


  • Hunter Allen on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    I am unfortunately probably better-persuaded by reverse psychology, though I’m pretty sure my dad still thinks my priorities are little…

    May 26, 11:07


  • Hunter Allen on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    I didn’t even know there was an Omar Sharif one! Neat. Weird. I also thought The Conqueror came out in…

    May 26, 10:41


  • Dan Stalcup on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    I really need to catch some of the other Biblical epics of the era, most of which I’ve seen parts…

    May 26, 09:47


  • Dan Stalcup on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    I’m not sure you both are even talking about the same Genghis Khan movie, haha! There’s 1956 The Conqueror with…

    May 26, 09:39


  • Dan Stalcup on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    I knew DeMille by reputation as conservative, although this comment sent me down a little more of a DeMille biography…

    May 26, 09:35


  • Dan Stalcup on The Ten Commandments (1956):

    One of the great pleasures of diving deeper into film history is learning that every era had its geniuses and…

    May 26, 09:31



Dan is the founder and head critic of The Goods. Follow Dan on Letterboxd. Join the Discord for updates and discussion.