Recent Comments

  • Hunter Allen on Final Destination 2 (2003):

    I no longer endorse this; I have completely flipped on the issue. 1 is, in fact, best, and you were…

    Jan 24, 13:55


  • Mitch on F1 (2025):

    Spiderhead reeks. “rehydrating the raisin” is funny. I appreciate the observation about sports and war movie ouroboros. This is about…

    Jan 21, 18:35


  • ED on The Blackening (2022):

    Hi-diddle-hi-de-die Murderinos! Since I’m neither a fan of the Slasher genre nor a Black American the film might well have…

    Jan 21, 08:29


  • Dan Stalcup on Wicked (2024):

    The Goods: giving half-hearted pans of blockbuster slop so you don’t have to watch it since 2020

    Jan 16, 09:05


  • Nate on Wicked (2024):

    A mutual friend of ours, a big movie fan and one who has generally resisted my laments that modern cinema…

    Jan 15, 15:46


  • Dan Stalcup on Eternity (2025):

    I definitely should give The Good Place another shot. And I hope Eternity works better for you than it did…

    Jan 12, 20:21


  • idk_Very_much on Eternity (2025):

    You really should. IMO, the series finale earns every bit of the hype around it. Though I did prefer S2-3…

    Jan 12, 20:04


  • Dan Stalcup on My OFCS Nominating Ballot (2025):

    Jan 11, 17:08


  • Dan Stalcup on My OFCS Nominating Ballot (2025):

    DCOM representation in legitimate awards bodies. That’s why I’m here. ✊

    Jan 11, 14:54


  • Andrew Milne on Eternity (2025):

    Vaguely! I said vaguely interesting!

    Jan 11, 13:05


  • Andrew Milne on My OFCS Nominating Ballot (2025):

    You really did put Z-O-M-B-I-E-S 4 in as your top pick for choreography, you actual madman.

    Jan 11, 13:03


  • Dan Stalcup on The Train (1964):

    Love seeing the enthusiastic comments for The Train. Great film

    Jan 11, 12:12


  • Dan Stalcup on Eternity (2025):

    It is now occurring to me that the Lubitsch aside I read was probably a reference to Heaven Can Wait,…

    Jan 11, 09:18


  • Dan Stalcup on Eternity (2025):

    I did feel like I was being a grump about a good-natured original story, so maybe follow your instincts and…

    Jan 11, 09:15


  • Hunter Allen on Eternity (2025):

    I dunno, the one Lubitsch movie I’ve seen that I don’t like is in fact his celestial bureaucracy movie (not…

    Jan 10, 02:22


  • Zola Lloyd on Mulholland Dr. (2001):

    If IMDB Trivia for this film is to be believed, the Betty/Diane character of wanting to become a big star…

    Jan 8, 15:12


  • Zola Lloyd on Memento (2000):

    Memento remains one my challenging favourites, not least for the rather beguiling performance from Guy Pearce (Even though he went…

    Jan 8, 14:03


  • Andrew Milne on Eternity (2025):

    I thought the trailer for this was vaguely interesting, but comparisons to Wish. Lol, oof.

    Jan 8, 09:47


  • Chris Wilson on The Train (1964):

    One of the great WWII films and from a railway standpoint, an unforgettable feast of steam. The entire cast, direction,…

    Jan 7, 23:38


  • Dan Stalcup on Podcast Episode: Dear Christmas (2020) ft. Brennan Klein – A cookie-cutter Christmas:

    Happy New Year, ED! 2026 gotta be a good one. We’re overdue as a human race, right? (Honestly, both 2024…

    Jan 1, 21:56


  • Dan Stalcup on Podcast Episode: It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) and Christmas Carol roulette – I’m thinking of beginning things:

    An even more belated happy holidays to you, ED! I hope you are well! Ha, I haven’t even heard of…

    Jan 1, 21:53


  • ED on Podcast Episode: Dear Christmas (2020) ft. Brennan Klein – A cookie-cutter Christmas:

    A very happy new year to you – may AD 2026 deliver THE GOODS just as well as your own…

    Jan 1, 08:13


  • ED on Podcast Episode: It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) and Christmas Carol roulette – I’m thinking of beginning things:

    A belated Merry Christmas to you and all the Joy of the Season – especially the Joy of no longer…

    Dec 26, 12:32


  • Bob on The Train (1964):

    The usage of b&w sets this offering above many others. Having spent five plus year in France military and transportation…

    Dec 20, 13:08


  • Mitch on After the Hunt (2025):

    First of all, this is a fantastic piece of film criticism. I admire how much you grapple with the movie.…

    Dec 12, 10:02


  • Dan Stalcup on Rushmore (1998):

    Sorry this one didn’t jibe with you (the movie or the review), but thanks for stopping by!

    Dec 10, 20:51


  • Maxbert on Rushmore (1998):

    A lot of words spent on a boring movie.

    Dec 10, 02:44


  • Hunter Allen on Good Boy (2025):

    I’d argue, but I’m pretty sure the cat in Caught Stealing and the Pet Sematary remake must be on barbituates.…

    Dec 9, 19:20


  • ED on Good Boy (2025):

    Well you’d have small children about the house, so you have all the fun and many of the frustrations involved…

    Dec 8, 08:02


  • ED on Good Boy (2025):

    Sir, I am not what you call a Dog Person (I remained mortally afraid for them for many years and…

    Dec 8, 07:59


  • Dan Stalcup on A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving (1973):

    🙏

    Dec 7, 17:47


  • Dan Stalcup on Good Boy (2025):

    Getting an obedient dog to act is one thing, but I can’t even imagine it for a cat. We’ll have…

    Dec 7, 17:46


  • Hunter Allen on Good Boy (2025):

    Dogs probably dream; there’s been a study on pigeon sleep that’s suggestive that they dream, which given mammals’ evolutionary distance…

    Dec 7, 13:46


  • Dan Stalcup on Eddington (2025):

    In a vacuum, I intellectually appreciate your position. And yet everything about Eddington just puts me off it. Maybe if…

    Dec 2, 15:44


  • Mitch on Eddington (2025):

    Not to make you think about this more since you’ve already hit publish, but I think I started basically where…

    Nov 29, 16:58


  • Mitch on A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving (1973):

    Well put!

    Nov 27, 10:03


  • ED on Frankenstein (2025):

    Ahem. “… just listen to Mr Patrick Doyle’s score for FRANKENSTEIN (Kenneth Branagh) and you’ll hear exactly the towering passions…

    Nov 24, 15:53


  • ED on Frankenstein (2025):

    If this film did nothing else, it gave me a mental image of Ms Mia Goth delivering the immortal line…

    Nov 24, 15:51


  • Dan Stalcup on Community – Pilot (S01E01):

    I’ve never seen Frasier 😅. Always assumed I’d like it. Good to read another endorsement.

    Nov 23, 16:30


  • Dan Stalcup on Frankenstein (2025):

    Meanwhile The Phoenician Scheme, which I loved, is probably on track to get none. I’ve only seen 2 of the…

    Nov 23, 16:29


  • Nate on Community – Pilot (S01E01):

    I’m not totally sure how I missed this one, given that I like a lot of the other shows from…

    Nov 22, 01:52


  • Hunter Allen on Frankenstein (2025):

    Yep. Thinking on it, the music might be the most perplexingly bad part; maybe Desplat didn’t want to be inconsistent.…

    Nov 21, 12:08


  • Dan Stalcup on Community – Pilot (S01E01):

    Always glad to encounter a fellow Human Being, though as you note there are many of us. I have a…

    Nov 18, 11:57


  • Hunter Allen on Community – Pilot (S01E01):

    Probably my favorite sitcom, which I feel ill at-ease with because it’s everybody’s favorite sitcom (that’s obviously not really true,…

    Nov 18, 02:15


  • Nate on Him (2025):

    “Maybe movies that make my heart glow even when I feel intellectually dishonest recommending them are actually good movies.” Unironically…

    Nov 17, 01:01


  • Andrew Milne on Community – Pilot (S01E01):

    I get that. It’s interesting to get the perspective of someone who was immersed in the context of U.S. sitcoms…

    Nov 16, 13:29


  • Dan Stalcup on Once (2007):

    Great recommendation by you. I’ll def be checking out at least Sing Street. Yeah Katy’s feedback as we watched was…

    Nov 16, 08:52


  • Dan Stalcup on Community – Pilot (S01E01):

    Maybe! I’m glad to know I’d have someone following along. I’ve always wanted to write more about the show, and…

    Nov 16, 08:36


  • Andrew Milne on Community – Pilot (S01E01):

    Ooh, are you doing a series on Community, Dan? That’s a big undertaking, and I’m here for it! (Love this…

    Nov 16, 04:06


  • Nate on Once (2007):

    Would’ve been surprised if you didn’t like this at all, but I’m still pleased to see such a high rating.…

    Nov 16, 00:29



Dan is the founder and head critic of The Goods. Follow Dan on Letterboxd. Join the Discord for updates and discussion.